[CDSNL] False "Great Leap Forward" in AI

[Juyang Weng]

Dear Asim,
   It is my great pleasure to finally have somebody who argued with me
about this important subject.   I have attached the summary of this
important issue in pdf.
   I alleged widespread false data in AI from the following two misconducts:
   Misconduct 1: Cheating in the absence of a test.
   Misconduct 2: Hiding bad-looking data.
   The following is a series of events during WCCI 2024 in Yokohama Japan.
These examples showed that some active researchers in the WCCI community
were probably not aware of the severity and urgency of the issue.
   July 1, in public eyes, Robert Cozma banned the chance for Simon See at
NVidea to respond to my question pointing to a False "Great Leap Forward"
in AI.
   July 1, Kenji Doya suggested something like "let misconduct go ahead
without a correction" because the publications are not cited.  But he still
did not know that I alleged that AlphaFold as well as many almost all
published Google's deep learning products suffer from the same
Post-Selection misconduct.
   July 1, Asim Roy said to me "We need to talk" but he did not stay around
to talk.  I had a long debate during the Banquet last night.  He seems to
imply that post-selections of few networks and hiding the performance
information of the entire population is "survival of the fittest".  He did
not seem to agree that all 3 billion human populations need to be taken
into account in human evolution, at least a large number of samples like in
human sensus.
   July 3, Yaochu Jin did not let me ask questions after a keynote talk.
Later he seemed to admit that many people in AI only report the data they
like.
   July 3, Kalanmoy Deb said that he just wanted to find a solution using
genetic algorithms but did not know that his so-called solution did not
have a test at all.
   July 1, I saw all books on the display on the Springer Table appear to
suffer from Post-Selection misconduct.
   Do we have a false data flooded "Great Leap Forward" in AI?  Why?
   I welcome all those interested to discuss this important issue.
   Best regards,
-John Weng
-- 
Juyang (John) Weng
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.cse.msu.edu/pipermail/amdnl/attachments/20240704/3de4c008/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: IJCNN-2024-PS-flier-2-sides.pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 967228 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.cse.msu.edu/pipermail/amdnl/attachments/20240704/3de4c008/attachment-0001.pdf>